Today we got a 10 minutes video showing the entire first world, consisting of 8 stages and a boss.
Source: Giana's Return Progress Blog
Giana's Return - World 1 betatesting video
-
Juan
- DCEmu Commie
- Posts: 3351
- Joined: Sun Jun 15, 2003 11:47 pm
- Location: Montevideo
- Has liked: 21 times
- Been liked: 0
Giana's Return - World 1 betatesting video
Today we got a 10 minutes video showing the entire first world, consisting of 8 stages and a boss.
Source: Giana's Return Progress Blog
-
Christuserloeser
- Moderator
- Posts: 5941
- Joined: Thu Aug 28, 2003 12:16 am
- Location: DCEvolution.net
- Has liked: 6 times
- Been liked: 0
- Contact:
Re: Giana's Return - World 1 betatesting video
Looking very good, but there are a few things that I think could be improved:
(I hope that Kojote reads this)
1. (and most important:) the jumping sound effect! - I would recommend to use one similar to the C64 version, the current one from the Amiga version is just awful.
Here's a video of the C64 version:
2. 8 stages using one and the same graphical theme is just waaaay too much. Why not having an easy/normal/hard mode with a different number of stages ?
3. Grey, dark green and... brown ? o_O ...where's the purple from the earlier beta screenshots ? Why would one choose these uninspired dark colors ?
4. I really like the music but two themes + boss track for 8 stages gets old VERY quickly. Again, I propose to offer easy/normal/hard modes with less stages.
Also, where is the tune from the preview/trailer video ?
5. I see way too many trees... - I liked the pipes from the original and the earlier betas. Where are they ?
(I hope that Kojote reads this)
1. (and most important:) the jumping sound effect! - I would recommend to use one similar to the C64 version, the current one from the Amiga version is just awful.
Here's a video of the C64 version:
2. 8 stages using one and the same graphical theme is just waaaay too much. Why not having an easy/normal/hard mode with a different number of stages ?
3. Grey, dark green and... brown ? o_O ...where's the purple from the earlier beta screenshots ? Why would one choose these uninspired dark colors ?
4. I really like the music but two themes + boss track for 8 stages gets old VERY quickly. Again, I propose to offer easy/normal/hard modes with less stages.
Also, where is the tune from the preview/trailer video ?
5. I see way too many trees... - I liked the pipes from the original and the earlier betas. Where are they ?
Insane homebrew collector.
-
Sweater Fish
- Psychotic DCEmu
- Posts: 679
- Joined: Wed Oct 17, 2001 7:44 pm
- Has liked: 0
- Been liked: 0
Re: Giana's Return - World 1 betatesting video
The only one of christuserloeser's points that I really agree about it is the color choices. The purple bricks look much better. They definitely enhance the stormy theme you're developing for the first world.
Otherwise I like the looks of this a lot.
I think you may be overusing the foreground layer. Having your character and the enemies obscured by foreground objects leads to a lot of unecessary frustration. Difficulty should come from good level design, not cheap tricks like enemies you can't see because they're behind a rock.
Also, how will the fireballs/lightning work in this version? They don't seem to bounce like they did in the original game and the earlier version of Giana's return released a few years ago. That was a great concept and I hope you haven't abandoned it for this version as it can really add a lot to the gameplay if the level design takes proper advantage of it.
I can't wait for a release. Try not to bludgeon us with videos, though. I don't want to see the entire game being played before I ever get a chance to play it myself (so "don't watch any more of the movies we release," right?)
...word is bondage...
Otherwise I like the looks of this a lot.
I think you may be overusing the foreground layer. Having your character and the enemies obscured by foreground objects leads to a lot of unecessary frustration. Difficulty should come from good level design, not cheap tricks like enemies you can't see because they're behind a rock.
Also, how will the fireballs/lightning work in this version? They don't seem to bounce like they did in the original game and the earlier version of Giana's return released a few years ago. That was a great concept and I hope you haven't abandoned it for this version as it can really add a lot to the gameplay if the level design takes proper advantage of it.
I can't wait for a release. Try not to bludgeon us with videos, though. I don't want to see the entire game being played before I ever get a chance to play it myself (so "don't watch any more of the movies we release," right?)
...word is bondage...