Even though I lurk more than post, here's my thoughts:
Best Overall Poster: BoneyCork
Most Improved Poster: Christuserloeser
Next Big Thing: American Hip-Hop/Balinese Gamelan Fusion Music
Most under-rated poster: Hasney
Please come back: FETUS/Quzar/Scherzo
Nicest Poster: BlueCrab/curt_grymala
Forum-has-Been: Jeeba Jabba
Best Australian Poster: JellyWarrior
Best European Poster: BoneyCork
Best Canadian Poster: ace
Best AMERICAN Poster: melancholy
Most SEXIEST: ace!
Most Creative Poster: AgentGreen
Most overused phrase: Discuss
Post of the Year: Hasney Love Song
Best Overall Poster: BoneyCork
Most Improved Poster: butters
Next Big Thing: linlinlol's ass
Most under-rated poster: DaMadFiddler
Please come back: Covar
Nicest Poster: Soully
Forum-has-Been: me
Best Australian Poster: JellyWarrior
Best European Poster: BoneyCork
Best Canadian Poster: ace
Best AMERICAN Poster: melancholy
Most SEXIEST: Soully
Most Creative Poster: BoneyCork
Most overused phrase: Discuss
Post of the Year: Hasney Tribute
Ph'nglui mglw'nafh mankrip Hell's end wgah'nagl fhtagn.
==-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-== Dev blog / Twitter / YouTube